| A.E. Pitcher | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 1934 | Sheridan | Sectional |
| 1935 | Richmond | Sectional |
| Rushville | Regional | |
| 1936 | New Castle | Sectional |
| 1937 | Greensburg | Sectional |
| 1938 | Batesville | Sectional |
| 1939 | Jeffersonville | Sectional |
| 1940 | Seymour | Sectional |
| 1941 | Madison | Sectional |
| 1942 | Plainfield | Sectional |
| 1943 | Frankfort | Sectional |
| 1944 | Franklin | Sectional |
| 1945 | Anderson | Sectional |