| Butch Lehman | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 1996 | Fort Wayne Wayne | Sectional |
| 1997 | Plymouth | Sectional |
| 1998 | Garrett | Sectional |
| 1999 | Penn | Sectional |
| 2000 | Michigan City | Sectional |
| 2001 | Triton | Sectional |
| 2002 | NorthWood | Sectional |
| 2004 | Elkhart Central | Sectional |
| 2005 | Wheeler | Sectional |
| Michigan City | Regional | |
| 2006 | East Noble | Sectional |
| Plymouth | Regional | |
| 2007 | Elkhart Central | Sectional |
| Plymouth | Regional | |
| 2008 | Elkhart Central | Sectional |
| Plymouth | Regional | |