| Don McCoy | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 1951 | Auburn-Garrett | Sectional |
| 1952 | Winchester | Sectional |
| 1953 | Muncie | Sectional |
| 1954 | South Bend | Sectional |
| 1955 | Elkhart | Sectional |
| 1956 | Anderson | Sectional |
| Hammond | Regional | |
| 1957 | Winchester | Sectional |
| Elkhart | Regional | |
| 1958 | Syracuse | Sectional |
| East Chicago | Regional | |
| 1959 | Peru | Sectional |
| Indianapolis | Regional | |
| 1960 | Elkhart | Sectional |
| New Castle | Regional | |
| Indianapolis | Semistate | |
| 1962 | Plymouth | Sectional |
| Marion | Regional | |
| 1963 | Anderson | Sectional |
| Lafayette | Regional | |
| 1964 | Chesterton | Sectional |
| Indianapolis | Regional | |