| James P. Carey | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 1958 | Noblesville | Sectional |
| 1959 | Wabash | Sectional |
| 1960 | Columbia City | Sectional |
| 1961 | Fort Wayne | Sectional |
| 1962 | Richmond | Sectional |
| 1963 | Southport | Sectional |
| 1964 | Kendallville | Sectional |
| 1965 | Greensburg | Sectional |
| 1966 | South Bend | Sectional |
| 1967 | Fort Wayne (#2) | Sectional |
| 1968 | Warsaw | Sectional |
| Bloomington | Regional | |
| 1969 | Southport | Sectional |
| South Bend | Regional | |
| 1970 | Ben Davis | Sectional |
| Columbus | Regional | |
| 1971 | Batesville | Sectional |
| Lafayette | Regional | |
| 1972 | Indianapolis | Sectional |
| South Bend | Regional | |