| L.I. Mattingly | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 1917 | Crawfordsville | Sectional |
| 1918 | Rochester | Sectional |
| 1919 | Rochester | Sectional |
| West Lafayette | Finals | |
| 1920 | Rochester | Sectional |
| 1921 | Rochester | Sectional |
| 1922 | Marion | Sectional |
| 1923 | Kokomo | Sectional |
| 1924 | Rochester | Sectional |
| 1925 | Crawfordsville | Sectional |
| 1926 | Peru | Sectional |
| 1927 | Rochester | Sectional |